by Louise Walters
This kind of book is not my usual thing (hence the shelf tag). I don’t tend to enjoy psychological stuff (except maybe exciting murder mysteries) but I’m not keen on looking deeply into people’s lives and working out why they tick. Not in real life set ups anyway. Chuck in a few dragons and I’m awayβ¦
Anyway, I bought this for my mum for Christmas as I follow the author/publisher on Twitter and she was struggling to pay a bill, so every little helps as they say. My mum loved it! Loved it. She raved about it, and I was intrigued.
It takes place both in the past and the present. The past story starts in the 1950s and carries on up to the late 60s. It starts with Lucia and her family, she is the only girl in a family of 5 children. She loves her big brother Edward, who is ten years older than her, and very cool. Robert and Ambrose are bit players, just side characters. William the youngest, born when Lucia is 6, is kind of important but also barely appears. I’ll explain, if I canβ¦
The present part of the story is told by Tina, who is 46 year old woman, who is a little bit away with the fairies. When she was eight, her twin sister died and Tina has spent the last 38 years blaming herself for the death – she had put herself and her sister in danger and the sister died. Her husband, Keaton, is madly in love with her but is starting to get to a point where he needs her to get over the death of her sister. Tina still sees Meg, her sister. She can talk to her, hear her answers. Meg tells her to do things that Tina isn’t happy about, but she does anyway.
As the two stories go forward, we learn about Lucia back in the 50s and 60s and what happened to her and why she became the adult she became. Her story becomes intwined with Meg and Tina’s, as William, the younger brother, is their father. But when Meg dies, the girls’ mother takes off and abandons the daughter left behind. William does his best but is clueless and turns to drink. Tina, aged 8 and having lost her sister (although she doesn’t think she has as Meg is still there, just no one else can see her) moves in with her granny and Aunt Lucia and Uncle Edward.
The years between Tina being about ten, and 46 are kind of missed out, but I don’t think they are very important.
At 46, she meets a lady called Kath who helps her to come to terms with the death of her sister, and Tina comes to understand that she was 8 years old and it really wasn’t her fault, and it was Lucia’s words on the day “Tina! What have you done!” that made Tina believe for so long that she was to blame.
This was an intriguing book and, as I say, not my usual cup of tea, but I enjoyed it and it kept me up until 1am so it can’t have been bad! I don’t know that I particularly liked any of the characters, even Tina, the protagonist, was hard to like due to the way she allowed her dead sister to manipulate her, and she hurt people who loved her because of it. But it is a mental illness, perhaps, so she can’t really be blamed.
People are complicated beasts, and I do feel that the world would be a better place without them. What a mess we leave behind. Meg was not nice to her sister, but she was badly treated by the adults around her. I think if we just all practised kindness towards others, maybe we would have less damaged people. But what do I know?
4 stars.